Katherine Wilson-Smith
“A View From the Roof of the Residence.” Twenty One Years at Mansfield Home, 1890-1911. Plaistow: W. S. Caines, 1911. 1.
“From the roof of the Settlement one appears over an enormous, monotonous, dingy sea of homes, acre upon acre, mile upon mile, in lengthy inflexible rows – like frozen waves of the gray sea – damaged solely by gaunt chimneys and tapering masts to point out the restrict of the docks.”1
On 11 December 1899, this bleak scene greeted J.S. Woodsworth upon his arrival at Mansfield Home, in London’s East Finish, the place he spent two weeks over the Christmas break. Woodsworth resided at Mansfield Home for a short while, however his daughter credited this temporary sojourn with placing her father on the trail to changing into the eventual chief of the CCF: the poverty he witnessed throughout his brief time within the East Finish was each personally surprising and a jolt in the direction of sensible motion.2 Lower than a decade later, Woodsworth turned the superintendent of the All Folks’s Mission in Winnipeg. There, his management can be impressed by the ideas and practices he had noticed in London and particularly, using Christian socialist values to foster a non-denominational atmosphere by which the entire group was welcome. This considerably neglected interval of Woodsworth’s life and his ties with the settlement motion are important to understanding his political and ideological growth, which is reflective of the broader local weather of transnational socialism on the flip of the century.
Mansfield Home was in Canning City, a particularly poor neighbourhood that was reliant on the docks for work and residential to giant pockets of immigrants, east of the Metropolitan space of London and simply earlier than the Essex marshes. The settlement, which took up residence in a row of former outlets, introduced the allure and middle-class respectability of Mansfield School, Oxford to the infamous slum. Residents residing at Mansfield have been Oxford college students and professors, “slumming” within the East Finish, concurrently investigating the lives of locals and residing amongst them.3 The general public-facing rooms within the settlement have been supposed to be aspirational, as the home opened its doorways to the group on daily basis. Pre-arranged actions have been held in the course of the day for girls and boys golf equipment and within the night for working adults. If sporadic visits occurred, there was additionally workers at all times on name to help individuals on the doorstep.4
‘The Reception Room’, Twenty One Years at Mansfield Home, 1890-1911, p.13.
Mansfield School was the primary Oxford faculty to be related to non-conformist Christianity, and this attracted Woodsworth because the son of a distinguished Methodist minister. He was by no means absolutely enrolled within the college, selecting as an alternative to attend lectures and write an essay below the supervision of the faculty president, A.M. Fairbairn, with out matriculating. Fairbairn was a distinguished Christian socialist who, in 1884, mentioned the necessity to convey faith to the commercial working courses with extra sensible engagement first after which religious. This was a message which the settlement motion integrated into their work.5 The school, due to this fact, fostered a robust Christian socialist atmosphere and inspired its college students to take up social causes as an expression of their religion.
The settlement motion sought to convey males (and, in some circumstances, girls) from Britain’s most prestigious universities to its poorest areas, with the intention to educate the individuals and examine their situation.6 By transferring away from spiritual charity and in the direction of social investigation carried out by educated “specialists,” the settlement may interact extra individuals and experiment with long-term options to social issues. Professional investigation and recommendation have been more and more seen as key to sensible socialism, a view mirrored in actions such because the Fabian society and, in Canada, the League for Social Reconstruction. Some settlement staff might have been motivated by spiritual beliefs, however this was not on the forefront of the sensible features of their work.
Woodsworth was stunned by Mansfield Home’s vary of secular actions, from the Poor Man’s Lawyer service to lectures and ‘Nice Sunday Afternoon’ (PSA) discussions, however acknowledged that non-religious actions attracted crowds that spiritual actions couldn’t. The weekly PSA discussions have been a characteristic widespread to most settlements, as many held full of life debates and discussions as methods to introduce professional steerage to an more and more engaged, opinionated, and enfranchised individuals. A ‘tradition of debate’ developed in Britain after the Third Reform Act (1884) and subsequent municipal franchise growth, which inspired a rowdy and populist political tradition each within the press and among the many public.7 This unruly debate tradition sparked the rise of the “music corridor jingo,” a reactionary determine singled out by Mansfield’s warden Percy Alden as a caricature usually mistaken for the “true” voice of the individuals.8 Christian socialists argued that the “true” ideas of the individuals have been essentially good however have been susceptible to being led astray by the loudest shouters. Subsequently, having residents facilitating debate and appropriately educating debaters on the problems earlier than they spoke on them sought to counteract this. The emphasis on training at settlements carried into left-wing coverage, the place the training of staff was central to producing a robust left-wing motion.
Most of the residents believed the working class may obtain deeper perception than their middle-class counterparts with the suitable educating, as they have been thought-about “extra trustworthy” and “much less beholden to respectability.” A recount of a debate entitled, “Is there room for the aggressive thought within the kingdom of Jesus?” demonstrated the best way residents considered the debaters utilizing this lens. The resident observing the talk slotted the opinions of the working males in attendance (a few of whom weren’t spiritual) into philosophical positions.9 The resident mused that one man was “a thin-faced dialectician, who a yr in the past was a satisfied materialist, thus, demonstrating that the working males have been greater than able to deep and sophisticated educational thought.
J. S. Woodsworth was at Mansfield Home for a brief portion of his time at Oxford, however his experiences there fuelled each his need to be concerned within the Canadian settlement motion and the values he carried into it. These weeks at Mansfield Home supplied direct publicity to the city poverty that was usually described by the Christian socialists educating him. Years later in Winnipeg, Woodsworth lamented Canadians’ naivety concerning the risks of town to the ethical well being of working individuals, particularly in comparison with the British, and he sought to enlighten them by his work.
Woodsworth turned superintendent of the All Folks’s Mission, a Methodist settlement, in 1907 and noticed a possibility to form a quickly increasing metropolis. He probably considered the mission as an early intervention to stop the entrenched poverty and social points he had witnessed in London’s East Finish. In contrast to London, Winnipeg was a metropolis nonetheless establishing itself. The inhabitants rose from 42,340 in 1901 to 139,863 in 1908, after the Canadian Pacific Railway routed its line by town, making certain Winnipeg’s standing because the Gateway to the West.10 The speedy growth introduced with it the anxieties provoked by all city centres, and the settlement motion supplied an vital manner of tackling them.
As an overtly spiritual settlement, the All Folks’s Missions’ understandings of Christianity have been influenced by their settlement ideas. Woodsworth evoked the medieval church in his description of the mission’s goals, a typical characteristic of late nineteenth century socialism. He described the church as central to the social lifetime of medieval society; it was the place the place individuals would meet, and charity can be allotted. The position of a settlement such because the All Folks’s Mission was arguably comparable, offering spiritual instruction, a gathering house, and charitable assist to these in want. It sought to create a way of group within the metropolis in the identical manner {that a} nation parish would.
One other affect on the best way the settlement carried out its position may be seen following the most important migration to Canada within the twentieth century, between 1909 and 1913. By 1913, half of the international born inhabitants had arrived prior to now 5 years.11 Subsequently, settlements weren’t solely shaping increasing cities, but additionally the quite a few current immigrants who crammed them. The mission was on the forefront of constructing “new Canadians,” and promoted training as a way for assimilation and political participation. Making ready completely different ethnic and spiritual teams for assimilation into Canadian society started with investigating their cultural practices. Professional evaluation was central to this. Woodsworth dissected the cultural traditions of teams that interacted with the mission in his 1911 guide, My Neighbor. He described the “love of the dramatic” which made Italians a “nation of youngsters, born to show their world right into a stage.” This immensely patronizing if considerably optimistic view is indicative of the worth judgements made about completely different cultures by the “specialists” investigating them. Woodsworth clearly believed he noticed one of the best within the cultures he described, whereas additionally categorizing them utilizing requirements the place they’d at all times be discovered missing. The settlement’s concepts about investigating the poor, as noticed at Mansfield, took on a brand new edge when confronted with completely different ethnic teams in Winnipeg, as settlement staff have been eager to categorize immigrants with the intention to then goal their wants.
Programmes have been due to this fact designed to particularly interact with completely different ethnic teams. The Polish Institute supplied an English language evening college, and outreach on the Polish Church. The evening college lectures have been on “British and Canadian historical past,” and aimed to offering the context required to show the scholars concerning the British structure and British beliefs.12 The strategy to citizenship right here privileged British concepts above all else and noticed these values because the gateway to Canadian citizenship. Woodsworth praised the commerce union motion in Britain for educating newly enfranchised males about British historical past and democracy with the intention to make them “extra accountable” and “engaged” residents. He envisioned comparable ideas being fostered by the settlement.
One of many mission’s occasions particularly, the Sunday Afternoon Grand Theatre Conferences (extra generally referred to as ‘The Folks’s Discussion board’), mirrored the spirit of public training central to settlements on each side of the Atlantic. Woodsworth took direct inspiration from Mansfield Home right here. A newspaper article concerning the Discussion board declared the occasion was ‘based on a lot the identical traces because the previous nation “Nice Sunday Afternoons.”13 Nonetheless, the identify “The Folks’s Discussion board” implies a extra political, egalitarian and debate-focused ambiance. The playing cards promoting the lectures learn “Free Admission … Free Dialogue,” which was indicative of this ethos, though possibly not at all times the fact.14
Folks’s Discussion board Playing cards in J S Woodsworth Scrapbook. Canadiana.
Discussion board conferences had an analogous format to these at Mansfield, taking the type of a lecture by a visitor speaker, adopted by a dialogue by which the viewers have been inspired to take part, no matter their views. The visitor audio system have been drawn from the clergy, college professors, politicians, and union leaders. Bringing middle-class tradition to the decrease courses served by the mission was nonetheless a precedence, however right here the emphasis shifted from class to ethnicity, with a concentrate on demonstrating the prevalence of Anglo-Protestant tradition. The matters have been nonetheless variable, starting from travelogues with lantern slides and lectures on Tennyson, the latter given by Woodsworth, to discussions of the affect of the commercial revolution and the reforms wanted.15
The All Folks’s Mission was additionally clearly searching for to average political involvement by these debates, introducing immigrant teams to the “proper” types of political engagement and internet hosting debates on modern political points. As soon as once more, experiences of the discussions display that the voices of the labouring courses have been a prized a part of the discussion board, as a illustration of the true opinion of the individuals. A well-attended political discussion board happened in January 1910, the place ex-union chief Richard A. Rigg spoke on the “Beliefs of Organized Labour,” introducing the historical past and objectives of the commerce union motion. Rigg advocated for commerce unions within the British mannequin, versus the radicalism related to Russian Jewish teams, and included a piece on the ‘social paradise’ of the center ages in comparison with the arrival of wage labour.16 He had educated to be a Methodist minister in England, and his medievalist concepts aligned with the broader mission values, evoked by Woodsworth, about socialism rooted in a historically British mannequin. The frontier nature of Winnipeg additionally invited this reflection, as these working the settlement believed themselves to be on the forefront of shaping a brand new society, demonstrating the best way each wider Christian socialist thought and native issues have been intertwined in particular person settlements.
Woodsworth’s involvement with the settlement motion is an perception into each his private growth and the local weather of transnational Christian socialism. These concepts have been cast in a British context, however discovered their place throughout the English-speaking world, together with in Canada. Woodsworth would go on to be one of many founders the Cooperative Commonwealth Federation (the CCF), the place he continued to have a excessive regard for social investigation and a perception in utilizing grassroots group to affect coverage. Canadians resembling Woodsworth facilitated the stream and adaptation of concepts throughout the Atlantic. For him, a keep in Oxford confirmed rather more than simply the dreaming spires.
Katherine is a second yr masters pupil at McGill College. Her work largely focuses on faith and immigrant identification.
Associated
